After observing Ms. Garces’s tenth grade English
class, I have seen this improving and preparatory work in action. The class was
finishing up their Lord of the Flies
unit, and the teacher repeatedly asked questions that did not have only one
right answer. Most of these questions required the students to either analyze
or evaluate, so some type of evidence was needed in order to have a fully
developed answer. Ms. Garces and her student teacher went around the room asking
opinion-based questions to the students. The majority of the students used
textual proof to support their claims, and the teachers positively acknowledged
such inclusion of evidence. In this classroom, and at CFHS in general, I think
that a main focus is on having students think critically and support their
opinions with appropriate evidence that enhances their argument. This will
prepare them for either higher education or the work field.
In 1897, John Dewey enters the big picture with his
American model of education. He draws on the social aspects of education,
particularly working with the child to establish them socially. He believed
that learning was linked to the social community that surrounds the individual.
This is the main idea of Dewey’s Pedagogic
Creed, and I think that it is applicable at CFHS. To shape the students
into socially relevant individuals, the classes are designed to gather the
opinions of students. With these differing opinions, the students are taught to
support their claims in accordance with the acceptability of society.
More than seventy years later came Ivan Illich, whose
philosophy consisted of de-institutionalizing education- his book, Deschooling Society. Like Dewey, he did
believe that individuals are affected by and learn from their surroundings.
However, he concludes that schools do not equalize (as believed) but rather divide.
With Illich’s philosophy, the responsibility transfers from the student and becomes
dependent on the institution. Asides from fostering dependency, this system
also abrogates responsibility. However, I find a parallel to CFHS with the
diversity of classes that are offered to students. The students are able to choose
classes that best fit their interests, and I suppose that this can be connected
to Illich’s philosophy for this reason.
From my findings and experiences in the classrooms at
CFHS, it is clear that administrators and educators are working to create a
positive and healthy learning environment for the students. Now in 2014, I
think that Central Falls High School utilizes both Dewey and Illich’s
philosophies to shape their students for the world after high school. It
provides a safe environment for exploring paths and areas of study. Schools are
for finding a healthy balance between academics, morals, society, and agency. This
equality will yield informed, cooperative, educated individuals. Learning on an
individual level will produce significant life skills that will help students
now and in the future. Critical thinking, creativity, and independence are
fostered at Central Falls High School, and for these reasons, students will be
successful in all that they do in the future.